Fishing Vests or Fly Fishing Packs: What's Best For You?

Wading big water may require a waterproof pack.

Every angler knows that a successful fly fishing trip depends on more than just your fly rods and a handful of flies—organization and access to essential fishing gear can make or break your day on the water. That’s why the age-old question remains: vest or pack? I know when I have my vest I have too much of everything and can't find what I'm looking for. When I use a smaller pack, I always forget the one thing I really need.

Whether you reach for a classic fly-fishing vest, a modern sling pack, a versatile hip pack, or a rugged waterproof backpack, the decision often comes down to comfort, gear load, and fishing style. In this guide, we’ll break down the pros and cons of every major option, including chest packs, lumbar packs, waist packs, and submersible bags like the Fishpond Thunderhead Submersible and Wind River Roll-Top. From mesh fishing vests to nylon waterproof packs, we’ll help you gear up with confidence for your next fishing adventure.

Fly-Fishing Vest: A Timeless Choice for Simplicity and Access

The traditional fly fishing vest remains a trusted favorite for many anglers. Brands like Simms, Fishpond, and Orvis continue to refine this classic piece, integrating modern fabrics and smart pocket layouts. Just a note I am not sponsored or endorsed by any of these brands.

Why Choose a Vest?

• Instant access to tippet, fly boxes, floatant, and tools.

• Distributes weight evenly across shoulders—especially useful for long day trips.

• Works well with lanyards, net holders, and minimalist setups.

Downsides:

• Can get warm, even with mesh fishing models.

• Limited space for extras like a rain jacket or hydration system.

• Lacks waterproofing—stash electronics carefully.

Best Fly Fishing Vests:

• Simms Guide Vest – Durable and highly organized

• Fishpond Sagebrush Pro Mesh Vest – Lightweight and breathable

• Orvis Pro Vest – Great for both saltwater and freshwater use

Fly Fishing Packs: Sling, Hip, Chest, and Full Backpacks

Modern fly fishing packs come in a range of designs, each suited to a different kind of angler. Whether you're hiking deep into the backcountry, wading local streams, or chasing saltwater species, there's a fishing pack for you.

Sling Pack: Agile and Accessible

The sling pack, like the Patagonia Stealth Sling or the Fishpond Summit Sling, is worn over one shoulder and swings forward for quick access. Benefits include easy access to fly boxes, leaders, tools, and fly line. These packs keep your casting shoulder clear and your gear handy. On the downside, sling packs place all the weight on one shoulder, which can cause fatigue on longer days, and they may shift while you hike or wade.

Hip Pack / Lumbar Pack: Waist-Level Utility 

Hip packs or lumbar packs sit comfortably around your waist. Many anglers appreciate them for their balance and easy accessibility. They're especially good for keeping your fly fishing chest clear and cool in warm conditions.

You get quick access to essentials like tippet, fly boxes, and snacks, without overloading your back or shoulders. However, they can get wet if you’re wading deep, and they generally offer less space than a full backpack.

Chest Pack: Compact and Efficient

The chest pack is ideal for anglers who like to keep their gear front and center without overloading. Compact and designed for minimalist fishing, chest packs work especially well on day trips or when you're carrying a waist pack or small backpack behind.

The Simms Tributary Hybrid Chest Pack and Orvis Chest Pack are great examples. Just note: the chest-heavy layout can obstruct vision or feel bulky if you're layering or casting big flies like streamers.

Backpacks and Waterproof Packs: For the Gear-Heavy Angler

If you're venturing off-grid or fishing in rugged environments, a waterproof pack like the Fishpond Thunderhead Submersible Backpack or Wind River Roll-Top is your best bet. These fly fishing backpacks offer generous space for food, layers, extra fly boxes, and hydration gear. They're also ideal for float trips or travel with river outfitters. Pair them with a chest pack or lanyard to access frequently used items without unpacking.

Choosing the Right Setup for Your Fishing Gear: Pack or Vest?

If you’re still torn between a vest and a pack, think about your typical fishing day. Here's how different setups match different situations:

• For quick trips after work or minimalist fly fishing, a fly-fishing vest, mesh vest, or compact chest pack will keep things light and efficient.

• If you're out all day and want more storage, a sling pack or hip pack gives you access and mobility without too much bulk.

• Fishing in saltwater or deep wades? Go for a waterproof pack like the Thunderhead Submersible Backpack or Wind River model to keep your gear dry.

• Heading into the backcountry? Combine a full backpack with a chest pack or lanyard for the best of both worlds—gear storage and quick fly access.

• Love tossing streamers or carrying multiple fly boxes? A lumbar pack, waist pack, or sling pack provides space without overheating your upper body.

Final Thoughts: Fly Fish Smarter with the Right Gear System

Whether you're loyal to a traditional fly fishing vest or experimenting with high-performance fly fishing packs, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The key is finding a setup that fits your water, your gear, and your rhythm.

From trusted names like Simms Fishing, Orvis, Fishpond, and Patagonia, today’s gear options have evolved to meet every angler's needs. Whether you're carrying a couple of dries and some tippet, or loading up a waterproof backpack with rain gear, hydration, and streamers, the right system makes your time on the water more focused, more comfortable, and more fun.

So whether it's a pack or vest, get organized, stay dry, and enjoy the cast. Just double check you got everything.